What to cook first?

[Gellar]

My wife surprised me with a traeger. I feel like I need to set it off in life in the right direction.

 

[PAGOAT]

While I love steak on our pellet grill. The best thing we found the family likes is pork butts. Cheap easy and very good with your favorite sauce. Enjoy, your going to love the grill.

 

[JoltnJoe]

All of the above! For first big cook though I would go with the pork butt hard to mess up, versatile, and delightfully smokey. Enjoy!

 

[Nick87]

My favorite is a bone in turkey breast.

 

[Otto Matic]

You did NOT mention:
Salmon - marinated overnight
Kielbasa - homemade venison
Piglet - small, whole
Corn on the cob
Zucchini

Shame! Shame! Shame!

 

[Otto Matic]

My favorite is a bone in turkey breast.

Wild or Butterball?

 

[JLS]

I’d vote a couple racks of St Louis pork ribs.

 

[1_pointer]

While I love steak on our pellet grill. The best thing we found the family likes is pork butts. Cheap easy and very good with your favorite sauce. Enjoy, your going to love the grill.

I second this suggestion, especially if you are new to smoking. Pork butts are very hard to do wrong. In second place, I'd suggest a brisket. Takes a little bit more attention, but in the end hard to mess up.

Best thing for me is to have a meat thermometer and to use it. Cook to temps and not time.

 

[Otto Matic]

I second this suggestion, especially if you are new to smoking. Pork butts are very hard to do wrong. In second place, I'd suggest a brisket. Takes a little bit more attention, but in the end hard to mess up.

Best thing for me is to have a meat thermometer and to use it. Cook to temps and not time.

Can't do it!
I'm a "timer man"!
But I prefer my BBQ with some texture. I've had the stuff that was a mouthful of mush and tough as a boot sole. Think I'd rather have the tough.

 

[Gellar]

I second this suggestion, especially if you are new to smoking. Pork butts are very hard to do wrong. In second place, I'd suggest a brisket. Takes a little bit more attention, but in the end hard to mess up.

Best thing for me is to have a meat thermometer and to use it. Cook to temps and not time.

Ive smoked a lot of meat and a few other things. Ive never had a pellet grill though. Always had an electric smoker that took a crap and started shocking me every time I'd plug it in so I havent had a smoker for a couple of years.

 

[Gellar]

Wild or Butterball?

You did NOT mention:
Salmon - marinated overnight
Kielbasa - homemade venison
Piglet - small, whole
Corn on the cob
Zucchini

Shame! Shame! Shame!

The salmon is all gone from last year, hopefully I will get a chance to renew the stock sometime this summer. Corn on the cob sounds good for a side! Although I a sure it is awesome, my wife would not touch a whole piglet.

 

[Gellar]

Wild or Butterball?

A smoke wild turkey breast basted in honey or maple syrup almost heaven a plate.

 

[LWC55]

Pork butt is probably the most fool proof if you don't smoke a lot. This may sound weird but I picked it up from a friend and it was surprisingly good. Buy a 5lb tube of bologna. Smoke whole or chunk up and slather in bbq sauce and smoke in pan Pretty darn tasty.

My other go to's are brisket, ribs, sausage, chicken, sausage, etc....

Crank it up and it also cooks a good steak, pork chops, chicken breast, etc...

 

[Otto Matic]

A smoke wild turkey breast basted in honey or maple syrup almost heaven a plate.

LOL!
No "sweet on meat"!
Now, drag a pan sausage patty through a pool of syrup or on a biscuit and jelly? You betcha! (I think it's the sweet/salty thing!)

 

[EYJONAS!]

I can't believe burgers aren't on this list.....

 

[Otto Matic]

I can't believe burgers aren't on this list.....

BURGERS!?
That's a sacrilege! LOL! !
A burger is why they invented cast iron skillets!
A burger ain't a burger unless there's grease dripping off your elbows!
Burger on a grill, indeed! LOL!

 

[Gellar]

I can't believe burgers aren't on this list.....

I grilled burgers and brats on Monday. Wish I would have had the new grill ready to go then. Burgers and brats are a regular staple on the grill year round.

 

[Dave N]

I just want to know who actually voted for leave it in the box?

 

[BirdManMike]

Chicken roast on the grill is the best thing there is.

 

[deer_shooter]

I agree with the pork butt suggestion although I cant believe brisket didn't make the list.