Montana’s Culture of Leniency Toward Poaching
- Thread starter MTGomer
- Start date
Labman
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2015
- Messages
- 489
https://www.scotusblog.com/2019/02/...ban-on-excessive-fines-applies-to-the-states/
Maybe the fines will increase now...
Maybe the fines will increase now...
Revenuer Man
New member
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2019
- Messages
- 23
Public pressure can work on judges and politicians, I have observed this first hand regarding drunk driving laws and sentencing in Virginia. When I started my law enforcement career 30 years ago, every Friday a lady from the local mothers against drunk driving chapter would attend court, sit in the front row and take notes on every drunk driving case. The presiding judge knew she was there and I believe this influenced his sentencing of convicted drunken drivers. The same might be done on G&F violations.
Concerning the huge fines handed out for game violations, I would guess most are never actually paid by the defendants. Our G&F officers recently arrested a man for poaching elk and deer, he was sentenced to 7 years in prison and fined 25k, I doubt the state will ever see a dime of that money.
Concerning the huge fines handed out for game violations, I would guess most are never actually paid by the defendants. Our G&F officers recently arrested a man for poaching elk and deer, he was sentenced to 7 years in prison and fined 25k, I doubt the state will ever see a dime of that money.
The poacher has filed a police report against me after I commented on this post
Concerning this story https://www.hunttalk.com/threads/elk-poached-near-roundup.291657/
And the lack of bite in sentences for these type of crimes.
Concerning this story https://www.hunttalk.com/threads/elk-poached-near-roundup.291657/
And the lack of bite in sentences for these type of crimes.
Carnage2011
Well-known member
Apparently for him, the truth hurts. Well done Riley!
Billings PD took over 6 hours to respond to my house for a buglery, 3 hours when my company Polaris Ranger and trailer was stolen.
But they wasted no time calling trying to shut me up, telling me to cease and desist, about posting the truth from publicly available records about this guy.
Unreal
But they wasted no time calling trying to shut me up, telling me to cease and desist, about posting the truth from publicly available records about this guy.
Unreal
Addicting
Well-known member
It’s all available under FOIA isn’t it?
Don’t even have to do that. We just called the clerk at the Court and asked for the sentencing documents.
This is what I wrote that got the complaint filed against me.
Addicting
Well-known member
Pretty sure that there is a amendment that covers free speech. I would think posting the truth is a freedom we have, what could the cops even do. It would be a civil matter anyway.
Scrappy
Well-known member
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2017
- Messages
- 255
I wished I had facebook and new how to share your info so I to could help make a poacher famous.
That’s definitely the stance I took.
The whole time on the phone I thought it was total bullshit and was just somebody he knew hoaxing me. I got the officers name, supervisor and report number and called the BPD. They verified it was legit.
Total BS. Nothing they can or will do, and as Ron White says ‘I may have the right to remain silent, but. not. The ability.
TheJason
Well-known member
- Joined
- Oct 21, 2024
- Messages
- 18,596
There is a big difference between censoring speech and informing someone an anti-harassment order could be filed (not necessarily granted).
A week or two ago, Matt Cool was busted trespassing on the NBar picking antlers.
Tracks resembling those on his tracked ATV he was using are reportedly all over the Little Snowies, off-road on both public and private lands.
Tracks resembling those on his tracked ATV he was using are reportedly all over the Little Snowies, off-road on both public and private lands.
diamond hitch
Well-known member
There is one thing to feed your family but wanton waste of a public resourse should be good for at least 5 years with a multiplier for each count. In the late 60s one of the locals single handedly killed all the big bulls in 124 for money and was hooked up with a taxidermist in Denver. Well documented in Montana outdoors at the time. By crossing state lines the Lacy act was evoked and it came out of the local courts.
For a problem child like this maybe its time to sit down with a legislator for some law modification.
For a problem child like this maybe its time to sit down with a legislator for some law modification.
Red Fox
Well-known member
If they keep letting him off easy he will never change
This story blows me away 1st what this guy did then the PD tring to keep MT gomer from talking about it that is nuts!!! we should take out a few bill boards around the area, like others have stated their is a little thing called the 1st amendment
But I think poaching has a lite sentence in many states Pa is the same we had some elk poached one was 460 class annd they didnt get what they should have either
But I think poaching has a lite sentence in many states Pa is the same we had some elk poached one was 460 class annd they didnt get what they should have either
matt0550
Well-known member
- Joined
- Apr 16, 2019
- Messages
- 271
Now if only everyone could get this wound up over the crimes committed against people as well, we'd really have something going. Dont get me wrong, the OP is absolutely correct - this type of sh*t needs to get to a vote where the penalties can be stiffened...but hey, as a nation we have done away with mandatory minimums for all but the most heinous of crimes. Unfortunately, the FEAR of punishment is ALL that keeps some marginal citizens from doing truly bad things...remove that fear and you see here what you get in exchange.
