Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Without the guide requirement the lower 48 sheep hunters would eat Alaska alive.
They could put in place an insurance requirement. Far less costly for the hunter than an outfitter. I believe you can buy coverage for getting airlifted and it is not horribly costly.If they were to ever remove the guide requirement,, the odds of drawing a license would take a dramatic change. It might even make the hunt largely out of reach for a different reason.
It is far easier to make a case to require a guide for non residents in very remote areas of Alaska than it is in the lower 48. It is very expensive to rescue a lost or injured hunter anywhere,, in Alaska even more so.
It's far easier for the state to have a guide requirement and be done with it, compared to verifying several hundred individuals for having insurance, every year.They could put in place an insurance requirement. Far less costly for the hunter than an outfitter. I believe you can buy coverage for getting airlifted and it is not horribly costly.
I guess some of us arnt made of that kind of money and can't even think about being able to afford to pay a guide/outfitterWell a NR could do a DIY sheep for $2500 or less vs $18,000 on guided. I'd call that pretty cheap. You're right nothing is cheap, but a guy going up to hunt caribou off the haul road spends very little in our economy. We could argue it till the cows come home, but IMO I really think NR could spend more, and I'm to the point that I just don't care to defend cheap hunting anymore. Its a vacation...
You could move up and go for the price of a tank of gas. I mean we're a welfare state it should be easy to get a job and live here.I guess some of us arnt made of that kind of money and can't even think about being able to afford to pay a guide/outfitter
I'm not saying I want it all, and my post was a little more pointed than I intended it and I was referring to more than jus Alaska and its sheep. I was referring to all states for hafting to have a guide for some of their North American game. It jus gets to me sometimes that some guys look at it that they think its just a rich man's game, and us middle of the road folks shouldn't even have a chance. And I'm not saying you think that, cuz I don't think you do. I'm jus throwing it out there. Ill shut up now. LolYou could move up and go for the price of a tank of gas. I mean we're a welfare state it should be easy to get a job and live here.
The states hold the wildlife in a trust for its citizens. Guide or no guide, a hunt out of state is a vacation. The cost is irrelevant. IMO. I wish it was cheaper to go to Hawaii.
Will a guide requirement really impact support to fund wildlife? 99.99% of hunters don't show up for anything except bitching about the price or availability of tags. Go to a management meeting sometime.
The older I get the less sympathetic I am to NR hunters who want it all.
Also the guiding requirement effectively reduces the number of hunters hunting brown/grizzly bears, sheep, goats.
For example, about 2400 hunter report hunting Dall sheep each year and the harvest is about 800 sheep each year.
Non-residents harvest about 40-50 percent of the sheep each year.
With no guiding requirement for non-residents, the cost would be $1000-$3000 DYI compared to $18,000-$20,000 guided.
A non-resident sheep tag cost is free for non-resident military, $800 for non-resident non-military.
Overcrowding is addressed by capping tag numbers.Apples to apples here folks...
MT elk v. AK caribou
MT sheep v. AK sheep
There isn't enough dall sheep that meet the requirements if the NR outfitter rule was lifted. You wanna see 30+ people in the field per maybe legal ram? What you seem to be missing is if that type of squeeze happened, transporter costs would skyrocket, my guess is 2-3x at a minimum. Considering prices are still on the rise despite covid. Yes you can walk in, but truth be told how many people in the lower 48 are even capable of hiking in 20+miles to get to a hunt area. On top of all of that, the dall sheep population has been in decline, just not legal ones.
tldr; more at play than you think.
My post wasn't really taking sides on the issue... more just highlight the comparison of the respective resources kinda flawed.Overcrowding is addressed by capping tag numbers.
I would gladly apply for 10-15 years for the chance to DIY a dall sheep.
I don’t see myself to ever be in a position to justify 20k$ (and rising)
for an outfitter.
I disagree. A good flogging does wonders for the gallery’s’ enjoyment, especially when accompanied by memes and gifs.Totally open to being educated here, and BuzzH when you read this take a deep breath and go easy on the flogging.