Gastro Gnome - Eat Better Wherever

Idaho governor refuses to apologize for ordering emergency hunt of escaped elk

Washington Hunter

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2002
Messages
4,133
Location
Rochester, Washington
Published November 05, 2006
Comments Print E-Mail Subscribe
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Idaho governor refuses to apologize for ordering emergency hunt of escaped elk


IDAHO FALLS, Idaho — A spokesman for Gov. Jim Risch says Risch will not apologize for ordering an emergency hunt in September for elk that escaped from a private hunting preserve even though the elk that were killed have tested negative for disease.

Risch signed an executive order Sept. 7 ordering the destruction of an estimated 160 domesticated elk that escaped in August from the Chief Joseph private hunting preserve operated by Rex Rammell near Ashton. Risch said the elk could spread disease and pollute the gene pool of wild elk in eastern Idaho.

Tests on 36 of the escaped elk killed have come back negative for chronic wasting disease, brucellosis, tuberculosis and red deer hybrid genes, said Wayne Hoffman, spokesman for the state Department of Agriculture.

“I knew they were negative — we tested them,” Rammell told the Post Register. “The only way they’d come up with a positive result was if they planted one. I think a few people owe the elk industry and me some apologies — Fish and Game, Governor Risch and some local guys.”

Brad Hoaglun, Risch’s spokesman, said an apology is not forthcoming.

“Absolutely not,” he said. “We hoped that there was nothing there, but it was a situation where we had to check and have these animals tested. Certainly, this is good news.”

Besides the elk that were killed, tests on 61 live elk at the hunting preserve did not show any signs of brucellosis or tuberculosis.

“We’ve been keeping our fingers crossed that the test results would come back negative,” said Steve Schmidt of the Department of Fish and Game. “If they come back positive, we’d have a real situation on our hands.”

Rammell said he plans to sue the state over the emergency hunt, which he said put him out of business. Hunters at the preserve paid upward of $5,000 to hunt trophy domestic elk.
 
my God he should be apologize to the people of Idaho for violating their trust, not maintaining his fences and blatantly disrespect for the law.This guy has some gall.

your right harleyyet only in Idaho.

When's Moosie going to tell us where he stands on game farms?
 
Apparently his tests were not trustworthy, don't people there have lab standards. No gene pollution, no disease and he had the tests to support he says. People are not communicating to well, it looks like.

Its like the old days, change, "the only good Indian is a dead Indian" to "the only good escaped private elk is a dead elk." Kind of primitive unfair, probably panic mode, thinking there, eh? That's what it seems like from here, especially if that guy had all his documents. Don't people go by data like that up there? No comment in the article about that data at all.

What do you do if a cattle cow escapes there, shoot it? Are they treated that way too? That would be relevent. Shit, I've heard of people being paid to ride into the wilderness and bring the escaped cattle out in New Mexico, don't they do that in Idaho too? Not shoot them, not if the papers support NO disease, NO red stag genes.

Prejudice sucks.
 
Tom said:
People are not communicating to well, it looks like.
:D |oo I often come to the same conclusion when reading your posts.... ;)



Tom said:
Its like the old days, change, "the only good Indian is a dead Indian" to "the only good escaped private elk is a dead elk." Kind of primitive unfair, probably panic mode, thinking there, eh? That's what it seems like from here, especially if that guy had all his documents. Don't people go by data like that up there? No comment in the article about that data at all.

What do you do if a cattle cow escapes there, shoot it? Are they treated that way too? That would be relevent. Shit, I've heard of people being paid to ride into the wilderness and bring the escaped cattle out in New Mexico, don't they do that in Idaho too? Not shoot them, not if the papers support NO disease, NO red stag genes.

Prejudice sucks.
If you don't know the biological differences betwix a cow and an elk, it will be a bit hard for you to understand the issue.
But, if you want to shoot domestic cattle on public lands, I will fully support your efforts. Go get 'em...
 
Cow season? I'm game. I will have to work out a different method for retrieval from the field though. Dunno if I would want to pack it out on my back, and I sure as heck can't pick one up to put it in my truck.

Tim
 
Ollin Magnetic Digiscoping Systems

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
113,585
Messages
2,026,023
Members
36,238
Latest member
3Wapiti
Back
Top