Best Sandwich Ever

[geewhiz]

If anybody is ever in bozeman go to the pickle barrell and order you up a philly. Get extra napkins. Thank me later.

 

[TOGIE]

I will say- I chose the Cuban over one I can’t believe isn’t on the list- the meatball sandwich.

I simply can’t believe nobody has mentioned a meatball sub/sandwich yet. It’s shocking, really.

I apologized early on for not putting it on the list

 

[Redman]

I voted for the Philly and Lobsta Roll. Both are perfect if done right.
I just can't believe the breaded pork tenderloin wasn't on here!!

 

[Brittany Chukarman]

Out of the list I picked a Reuben but my favorite is a BLT (usually hold the L) with a home grown freshly picked perfectly ripe tomato on toasted sourdough.

 

[R.K.]

I apologized early on for not putting it on the list

Completely missed that post. But it's my runner-up, for sure.

 

[mtmuley]

Make it public so we know who voted for the Big Mac

I love Big Macs. Not ashamed. mtmuley

 

[MaddH]

Ganglione Bros Philly cheesesteaks in San Diego are to die for

 

[EastTNHunter]

Homemade slow smoked brisket sandwich served open face on a toasted wheat roll with provolone, grilled onions and bell peppers, and A1 sauce

Homemade slow smoked (hickory) pulled pork butt

 

[Bullshot]

Twin lobster rolls two ways from Tuckaway Tavern in SE New Hampshire.

 

[TheTone]

My go to hunting sandwich is a bagel with cream cheese, sharp cheddar and smoked turkey. Used to make them daily when I was younger and worked every day in the woods. I always laid my pack in the sun for a bit to get a hot sandwich when it came time for lunch.

 

[Redman]

You 100% cannot get a lobster roll in a lot of places/states/regions and if you can 1/2 the time it's actually pollock.

Now the rest... maybe to some extent, but a lot of places have pretty dog chit Reuben's you really have to go to a Jewish Deli... BBQ in New England (Yikes), a lot of places really f-up a Philly... anyway.

"only certain regions/states/ cities have good food" -FIFY

WY- rough
MT- actually surprisingly has some decent spots
Denver/Chicago/Houston/SF/NYC - Excellent
The rest of Colorado
Boston- epically bad... might even say spectacularly... they manage to screw up take out Chinese, I'm not even setting the bar high here.

Chicago has the best Italian Beef hands down!

 

[jbseamus83]

Question- pulled mojo pork shoulder, or char-roasted and sliced?

For a Cuban I want the char-roasted and sliced. Mojo is good, but to me a cuban sandwich is sliced.

Now, for the pulled pork sandwich, I want a slow smoked pork butt. Throw a spicy slaw on top with a good bun, and you have a very fine sandwich.

 

[nwihunter]

This is probably a regional thing to the Chicago land area but I am a big fan of the combo. It’s an Italian beef with an Italian sausage in it. Pure heaven.

 

[geewhiz]

IM ON A FRIGGING DIET YOU GUYS!!!!!!!!

 

[longbow51]

You know, you alway crave what you can't have. We make great pulled pork and brisket, and burgers, and pretty good Reubens; friend does his own corned beef briskets and we do sauerkraut and marbled rye.

But, in Boston, we had great clam "sandwiches" that were basically just bread and lettuce plates filled with perfectly fried clams. Never got the knack of frying oysters or clams; not enough opportunity, I guess.

And in NOLA, had wonderful oyster loafs. I was getting out of a meeting and my wife called, and I asked what she was doing and she said, standing in line with a bunch of construction workers, they know what's good, right?

And boy did they ever. Turned out to be a neighborhood joint. Later on DDD; hope it didn't ruin them.

And our river breakfast was often grilled bagels with cream cheese with either Canadian or regular bacon.

And no one, I think, has mentioned The King's favorite: Fried Peanut Butter and banana.

 

[WoodMoose]

of those listed I went with Cuban and Rueben

but my favorite? A hunk of seared heart meat on a toasted (and buttered) bagel

 

[hank4elk]

Ruebens and corned elk and swiss Cantors deli style.
Pulled pork.
BLT or BLAT's ,avo added.
Having applewood ham and ementhal swiss grilled on whole wheat for dinner.

 

[shannerdrake]

I appreciate that the Rueben is getting the spot it deserves. Saddened that the Cuban is lagging though. Seriously!?!? It’s a grilled cheese, pulled pork, and hot ham sandwich on one.

Back to Ruebens, anyone ever in Indianapolis owes it to themselves to get one at Shapiro’s deli. It’s an honest Jewish deli in Indy. Their Reuben has placed nationally for best in the country.

 

[brockel]

Cheeseburger from the bar in Winston Montana. Everytime we go out that way I have to stop. Second choice is the sandwich I don’t have to make

 

[noharleyyet]

Cheeseburger from the bar in Winston Montana. Everytime we go out that way I have to stop. Second choice is the sandwich I don’t have to make

The ones you don’t have to make are called sammiches and I’m stopping right there.