Ban saw or slicer?

[cgasner1]

I want something electric to help cut the pile of meat I have headed my way. Does anyone know of a slicer that will do a 1” cut or do I have to go with a ban saw style set up

 

[Nick87]

If you can swing the saw I'd go that route. Slicer works well for jerky and such.

 

[Arcola]

I’m pretty sure you’re venturing into band saw territory there. I have a larger slicer (12” blade or so?) and it maxes out around 1/2”.

 

[cgasner1]

Thinking it’s gonna have to be a saw thought I would ask

 

[Nick87]

I’m pretty sure you’re venturing into band saw territory there. I have a larger slicer (12” blade or so?) and it maxes out around 1/2”.

Mine will cut thicker but it's not gonna be near as clean of a cut as a saw and it'll be a mess.

 

[Arcola]

Make sure you do some of those moose steaks 1.5” or so, though.

 

[Bluffgruff]

If you buy a band saw, I bet you could rent it out when you aren't using it.

 

[LIK2HNT]

The thought of thoroughly cleaning a band saw does not sound like much fun. I have had metal bandsaws both stationary and handheld, and the cutting oil gets up and into everything. Making a mess of shaving and oil. I assume blood, meat, and bone would get up into everything also. Unless there is something special about butchering bandsaws. As long as everything is deboned a long quality knife might be a better option.

 

[Dave N]

Ebay has some commercial meat cutting bandsaws for a variety of prices. More power means more money but it's a place to get an idea of what's out there.

 

[Wildabeest]

IMO, band saw is really only needed if you’re doing bone-in cuts. Otherwise you’re better off with a really high quality knife set for boning and then slicing. The only place a slicer would be beneficial for me would be shaving a corned or pastrami roast super thin for Reuben sandwiches. But really good and sharp knives can get me pretty darn close to what a slicer can do.

 

[Hem]

I would think frozen meat through a bandsaw would work pretty slick. Don't know from experience though.

 

[Dave N]

I would think frozen meat through a bandsaw would work pretty slick. Don't know from experience though.

Same here. If a butcher shop can get nice consistent cuts we should be able to do it! Any volume to cut would make it nicer than a knife. Sure, you would have to clean it but that's all part of processing. Freeze your big chunks, cut while frozen and package before they thaw.

 

[Hem]

Watch your fingers, one slip could be ugly.

 

[Wildabeest]

Watch your fingers, one slip could be ugly.

My dad was a butcher. All of his fingers were the same length.

 

[Wildabeest]

I would think frozen meat through a bandsaw would work pretty slick. Don't know from experience though.

If you ever watch bearded butchers YouTube stuff, the only time they ever use a band saw is when cutting bone-in meat such ribs, t-bones, ossobuco, etc. If they are cutting loins or roasts, it’s always with a good quality knife.

 

[cgasner1]

If you ever watch bearded butchers YouTube stuff, the only time they ever use a band saw is when cutting bone-in meat such ribs, t-bones, ossobuco, etc. If they are cutting loins or roasts, it’s always with a good quality knife.

I don’t watch YouTube. I’d assume he is not processing a couple elk a year. I got a moose this year to cut up and haven’t started elk hunting yet. Cutting a loin or roast up for a you tube video isn’t quite the same as 400# of meat I have sitting here

 

[longbow51]

Actually The Bearded Butchers are commercial butchers who run a meat market; they process entire animals all day every day. Well worth watching.

 

[Addicting]

If you ever watch bearded butchers YouTube stuff, the only time they ever use a band saw is when cutting bone-in meat such ribs, t-bones, ossobuco, etc. If they are cutting loins or roasts, it’s always with a good quality knife.

But the stuff they are cutting isn’t frozen.

 

[cgasner1]

I use to cut all my muscle groups up and put a slight freeze on them and run it thru the slicer worked great. Steaks are just to thin

 

[Addicting]

I don’t watch YouTube. I’d assume he is not processing a couple elk a year. I got a moose this year to cut up and haven’t started elk hunting yet. Cutting a loin or roast up for a you tube video isn’t quite the same as 400# of meat I have sitting here

I would ask your local processors. If they will do it at the end of the day before clean up. It may cost you a few extra hundred but it will be cheaper than a saw.

I had a harbor freight one, it did the job but was a PAI and the grinder portion was useless. But if you want cheap and then sell that would get you by.