I hunted the west side of the Bighorns on a Type 6 tag this year and it was a complete circus. The elk had left the forest due to snow but couldn't step foot on BLM without 30 hunters lined up in their trucks waiting to gun them down. Every single ridge and canyon had a truck or ATV path on it, legal or not. My hunting partner and I did a 17 mile hike one day in the most "remote" area of BLM in the unit and I don't think we ever made it 1/2 mile without crossing fresh ATV tracks.
My dad and I did glass up a herd of about 50 on opening morning right as it was getting light. The 2 mile hike took too long to get us on to them before they dropped into a canyon to bed. We laid on the side of the mountain for 8 hours and, sure enough, they started filtering back out to feed right where we saw them. As we waited for them to get a bit closer, 2 guys on ATV's flew up from behind them, guns blazing, and they were gone....
In the end we did find a pocket of elk to hunt and went 3 for 5 but I think we were very lucky to find them there. Any less snow would have allowed hunters to get their ATV's into the area and any more snow would have had them out of there and onto private land.
Had I known the ridiculous ATV use on the BLM I probably would not have applied. Even the wilderness study area I hiked across had ATV tracks every 100 yards. The only saving grace was the laziness of other hunters. The farthest we saw anyone venture from their vehicle was about 50 yards.
I'd definitely be hesitant to burn points on a Type 1 tag in the area. No snow would have the forest crawling with ATV's if it's anything like the BLM, and too much snow would have them hiding for their lives on private land. We did see a fair number of very nice bulls, so they are there, and with the right conditions I think you could have a good hunt, but I believe it would be a roll of the dice.
My dad and I did glass up a herd of about 50 on opening morning right as it was getting light. The 2 mile hike took too long to get us on to them before they dropped into a canyon to bed. We laid on the side of the mountain for 8 hours and, sure enough, they started filtering back out to feed right where we saw them. As we waited for them to get a bit closer, 2 guys on ATV's flew up from behind them, guns blazing, and they were gone....
In the end we did find a pocket of elk to hunt and went 3 for 5 but I think we were very lucky to find them there. Any less snow would have allowed hunters to get their ATV's into the area and any more snow would have had them out of there and onto private land.
Had I known the ridiculous ATV use on the BLM I probably would not have applied. Even the wilderness study area I hiked across had ATV tracks every 100 yards. The only saving grace was the laziness of other hunters. The farthest we saw anyone venture from their vehicle was about 50 yards.
I'd definitely be hesitant to burn points on a Type 1 tag in the area. No snow would have the forest crawling with ATV's if it's anything like the BLM, and too much snow would have them hiding for their lives on private land. We did see a fair number of very nice bulls, so they are there, and with the right conditions I think you could have a good hunt, but I believe it would be a roll of the dice.