Would you eat a CWD-positive animal?

[rjthehunter]

I only have them tested if it's mandatory. That being said, if it was a sick and unhealthy deer, and tested positive, maybe wouldn't eat. Otherwise, what doesn't kill you makes you stronger right?

I don't know how many deer I've eaten that haven't been tested... has to be over 40.

 

[WildWill]

Well again, comparing car accidents to something that hasn’t happened yet is indeed apples to oranges. I’m not arguing the number of dead from mad cow.

Maybe they are afraid vs stupid. Why do you care? It’s an individual decision. About as American as it gets.

Just encouraging people to use logic not fear when coming to that individual decision. Also how do you think it looks in the public eye when a guy shoots a deer throws it away then turns around and gets another tag even though he very well may throw it away too? Stuff like that is ammunition for antis attacking hunting and in place like Colorado they don't need anymore.

 

[INMT]

Just encouraging people to use logic not fear when coming to that individual decision. Also how do you think it looks in the public eye when a guy shoots a deer throws it away then turns around and gets another tag even though he very well may throw it away too? Stuff like that is ammunition for antis attacking hunting and in place like Colorado they don't need anymore.

What about science vs logic vs fear?Again, prion diseases (transmissible spongiform encephalopathy) have and can jump the species barrier. I think the antis would have more of a hey day if it jumps the barrier vs an extra allocated tag.

I eat untested deer, not arguing that side, just saying it’s possible.

 

[Forkyfinder]

They can’t test positive if you don’t get them tested

You sound like a buddy i knew in college

 

[Bigjay73]

HEY!! Don't you be bringing Little Debbie into this!

 

[Nick87]

If you have used a processor in an area where CWD is present, you have more than likely consumed prions.

I think about that all the time. (We do all our own, just the amount of deer that run through a processor though)

 

[INMT]

View attachment 350409

Too many Nutty Buddy’s topped with ice cream and bacon.

 

[Bullshot]

I have no intention of voluntarily testing any deer I shoot, but would refrain from shooting anything obviously sick. I have no worry about eating untested meat that I harvest. There are far more, and more serious things to worry about in life than some theoretical 1:100,000,000 or probably much smaller chance of being the first case of human CWD.

 

[Mountain Man]

Just encouraging people to use logic not fear when coming to that individual decision. Also how do you think it looks in the public eye when a guy shoots a deer throws it away then turns around and gets another tag even though he very well may throw it away too? Stuff like that is ammunition for antis attacking hunting and in place like Colorado they don't need anymore.

Where can you get an additional tag after having one test positive? I’ve not heard of that option before.

 

[ismith]

Well, if I ever test positive for CWD I'll probably start smoking menthol cigarettes like It was my 24th birthday again.

 

[INMT]

Where can you get an additional tag after having one test positive? I’ve not heard of that option before.

From MTFWP CWD FAQ page:

 

[huntnpack]

CDC still recommends against eating it.

I’m sure all of you will heed what the cdc says (yes sarcasm).

These encephalopathies often take decades to develop. So…maybe I’ll consume meat from a positive animal in decades. Either because I’m old enough not to worry much, or we’ve reached a population level of exposure with enough longevity that I’ll feel comfortable.

But caring for people with early onset dementia, CJD, head trauma from ladder falls, etc. has probably fed my bias in all sorts of ways and has influenced my behavior.

 

[Bigjay73]

Eat it, don't eat it, do whatever you wish. Why do people get so worked up over how other people live their lives?

 

[VikingsGuy]

Not stupid just afraid. And 232 is the total dead of mad cow disease as of 2019 not per year. If that ain't apples to apples nothing is.

If we get 232 confirmed human CWD deaths, I guarantee you the answers to this thread would change a lot.

As for car deaths - a complete red herring in every debate it is brought up.

 

[VikingsGuy]

Just encouraging people to use logic not fear when coming to that individual decision. Also how do you think it looks in the public eye when a guy shoots a deer throws it away then turns around and gets another tag even though he very well may throw it away too? Stuff like that is ammunition for antis attacking hunting and in place like Colorado they don't need anymore.

How do you think a few hundred CWD deaths in face of known tests results would play on TV?

 

[schmalts]

Hell no. I'll wait for more data and evidence to support that it can't transfer to humans. Although I have to admit that when someone has a pile of summer sausage I can't be 100 percent sure what's all in it but still eat it. But I'll ask if animal was shot in CWD area. Bottom line is I at least won't eat what is know to be sick animal

 

[WildWill]

Where can you get an additional tag after having one test positive? I’ve not heard of that option before.

Montana, Washington, Wisconsin, Minnesota that I know of.

 

[WildWill]

Eat it, don't eat it, do whatever you wish. Why do people get so worked up over how other people live their lives?

A combination of too many people in my house including the annoying sister in law and a personal pet peeve of the preface "I might eat cwd but I'm not feeding it to my kids" line had me in a piss poor mood. Just say you're not comfortable eating it and move on.


Anyway that foul hag is gone and I'm in the deer blind with my boy now and in a much better mood. So I'm bowing out on this one apologies if I offended anyone.

 

[Nick87]

annoying sister in law

foul hag is gone

I feel your pain my friend. Holidays are coming.

 

[mtmuley]

I feel your pain my friend. Holidays are coming.

I can relate to this. Foul hag. Cracked me up. mtmuley