pabearhunter
Well-known member
That again was a trigger problem not safety issue.
To chamber, or not to chamber? That is the question.
- Thread starter Ben Long
- Start date
That again was a trigger problem not safety issue.
The Hedgehog
Well-known member
An iPhoneX with a perfectly clear screen running OnXmaps couldn't lead you to your behind in a well lit closet.
Carry on - I will continue to be frightened by some of the people I see wearing orange and be-bopping around in the hills with a rifle.
onpoint
Well-known member
Not an observation about the comment you are commenting on, but - you must not read very much
...………………...pabearhunter
Well-known member
I am going to put a shell in the hole and going rabbit hunting. Bye
I can't believe how long this thread has gone.
The differences between flushing a bird and stalking big game seem pretty obvious. I always carry hot with a shotgun and have it in my hands with finger on or near the safety, and subconsciously check the safety often.
The rifle stays on my pack most of the time, so having a round loaded is not saving me that much time compared to the time it takes to get it off my pack. I've never missed a rifle shot opportunity because I didn't have a round chambered.
Interestingly, my shotgun is often treated like a rifle when hiking long distances for turkeys. Stays on the pack with no chambered shell.
The differences between flushing a bird and stalking big game seem pretty obvious. I always carry hot with a shotgun and have it in my hands with finger on or near the safety, and subconsciously check the safety often.
The rifle stays on my pack most of the time, so having a round loaded is not saving me that much time compared to the time it takes to get it off my pack. I've never missed a rifle shot opportunity because I didn't have a round chambered.
Interestingly, my shotgun is often treated like a rifle when hiking long distances for turkeys. Stays on the pack with no chambered shell.
beginnerhunter
Well-known member
- Joined
- Feb 15, 2016
- Messages
- 1,320
I mean, yeah pretty much. I agree, If my gun is strapped to my pack then there's no round in chamber. And slings are unstable IMO.
Maybe I have a different definition of still hunting than most (although a Minnesotan probably does it like I do). I'm talking about taking one slow step at a time, looking around, looking down, slowly stepping again, etc. Most of the time you're standing still. If I'm bebopping along then I'm not still hunting or planning on shooting anything so there's no round in chamber.
I'm not talking about hiking to a glassing point, watching game, quickly moving to another spot, etc. In that situation then no I wouldn't have a round chambered. Definitely agree with you there.
buckhunterhart
Member
1. Yes, with some exceptions
2. UT, ID
2. UT, ID
Not an observation about the comment you are commenting on, but - you must not read very much
I didn't say which spot it took in my top 10
Last edited:
ImBillT
Well-known member
- Joined
- Oct 29, 2018
- Messages
- 3,896
Remington major problems with the old triggers. Those problems were the ability of the sear to move while on safe, and the inability to open the bolt while on safe. Nonetheless, none of those people would have died if the person holding the gun hadn’t pointed it at someone. I’m glad they fixed the trigger issue. There is still no such thing as a trigger or safety that can’t fail or be accidentally taken off safe.
In a group of people with a gun packed or slung, it’s just too easy to point a barrel in a bad direction and too hard to keep track of all the people you can’t even see.
In a group of people with a gun packed or slung, it’s just too easy to point a barrel in a bad direction and too hard to keep track of all the people you can’t even see.
I simply won't hunt with someone who keeps a round chambered in their rifle. I certainly don't trust the judgment of a person who thinks he/she won't make a mistake. It takes less time to chamber a round than it does to identify and acquire one's target, unless one is the kind of person who will shoot movement.
Grundy53
Member
Time isn't really a factor for me it's the noise and movement. Where I hunt Roosevelt's and blacktails you often don't see them until you are within 20 or 30 yards. The bull I shot this year was under 10 yards. If I hadn't had a round chambered he wouldn't be in my freezer right now.
beginnerhunter
Well-known member
- Joined
- Feb 15, 2016
- Messages
- 1,320
I understand, but I disagree that the hunting manner in which I described earlier constitutes irresponsible firearm handling. And I see nothing in the hunter safety recommendations opposing my method: https://www.hunter-ed.com/montana/studyGuide/When-To-Load-a-Firearm/20102703_700164445/.
However, as I stated earlier, hunting in the west is different and I would gladly leave my gun completely unloaded if I ever go hunting with you. Let me know the time and place. I've got some Wyoming deer and elk points.
VikingsGuy
Well-known member
Do you think the guy in OP Facebook video would trade the meat in his freezer to get back the life of his friend?
beginnerhunter
Well-known member
- Joined
- Feb 15, 2016
- Messages
- 1,320
Yes, noise and movement. I'd never shoot at a target I'm unsure of, but I don't want to give away my position.
I bet you were carrying hot in South Dakota, no? Not all hunting situations are equal.
Edit: I’ve always carried hot, regardless. I will say this thread has made me rethink CERTAIN instances where it really isn’t warranted. Like mtmuley, I’ll be rethinking some of these, but also don’t think it’s a blanket caveat either. I’ve hiked thousands of miles behind a bird dog, carrying hot and no one thinks twice about it.
Last edited by a moderator:
Grundy53
Member
with that reasoning everyone should just quit hunting. People get shot by "empty guns" all the time. People get shot by people who don't have good backstops, they get shot by people who don't properly ID their target, they get shot by people who don't see them. None of those would be prevented by hunting without a round in the chamber. I am by myself 99% of the time and am always fanatical about muzzle control.
BrentD
Well-known member
Sounds more like you should join me
you know, I would love to. I really don't know of any grouse hunting that isn't a jungle, and all my pheasant hunting is in pretty knarly swamps with less than dependable ice, barbed wire, iced over cattails and sedges with lots of hummocks thrown in. I've never hunted birds where the hiking was as safe as western elk/deer/antelope hunting. Western hunting is pretty easy hiking for the most part with intermittent, but short intervals of thick stuff now and again. Bird hunting as I know it is a mud bog march/crawl/swim through who knows what.
We are going this weekend if you are interested.
BrentD
Well-known member
Oh, it is high and strenuous for sure, and elevation and weather will kill folks that aren't careful. But the quality of the footing is FAR better and safer than what midwestern upland bird hunter sees.
How many folks have the packed out of the Crazies so far this year? Did they stumble with their loaded guns and shoot themselves?
BrentD
Well-known member
Pretty much. Steep, but not too tough to stay upright relative to a midwestern cedar swamp.
Similar threads
