Guesses on Score?

[npaden]

148 might be a stretch but he has better mass, better tine length, and brows than any of those three that npaden shows pictures of.

On his right side I have:

G1	4
G2	12
G3	10
Mass 1	4
Mass 2	3.75
Mass 3	3.5
Mass. 4	3.25
Main beam	20

His left side is a little weaker but very similar, with a kicker.

Left	60.5
Right	60.5
Spread	17
Total	138

I’m probably 1-2” short on main beam length and I could be low on spread.

This is a 137” 8 point whitetail. Those g2s are 12”. People tend to guess high on whitetail scores.

 

[Gellar]

View attachment 349608
This is a 137” 8 point whitetail. Those g2s are 12”. People tend to guess high on whitetail scores.View attachment 349609

hopefully @PJ0311 can get a chance at him and we will see!

 

[Flatbrimmer]

I’m no professional but I taped this one out to only 138”. We all thought he’d score better. Still, 140” whitetail in Montana is NO deer to be passing on lol

 

[Gellar]

View attachment 349610
I’m no professional but I taped this one out to only 138”. We all thought he’d score better. Still, 140” whitetail in Montana is NO deer to be passing on lol

That one is comparable. I would say yours has better brows, similar g2s, shorter g3s, mass and width are similar. The buck in OP has a kicker on the g2. I’m thinking gross score, not net.

 

[Bc1992]

I would guess mid 130’s

 

[Mallardsx2]

130's buck I would say.

 

[buckbull]

It takes one hell of an 8pt to hit the 140" mark. Ill say 127".

 

[noharleyyet]

Good buck, low to mid 130.

 

[pabearhunter]

135 t0o 140.

 

[rjthehunter]

I'd guess 130-135.

 

[NEWHunter]

He’s a good deer. I’d shoot him and happily fork over the cash for a shoulder mount. That side profile makes it look like he might have a g4 on that left side. If that’s the case, plus the kicker on that side, he’ll be in the 130s somewhere. Ground check him for us please. Good luck!

142 for reference

 

[Hilljackoutlaw]

130...and very young!

 

[morley.tyler]

135" +/- 3". Takes a massive (By MT and ID standards) 4pt (8pt) to break 140"

 

[BAKPAKR]

If you decide to shoot him, please don’t shoot him in the head because we want an accurate inside spread measurement.

 

[okie archer]

It takes one hell of an 8pt to hit the 140" mark. Ill say 127".

So true

 

[okie archer]

View attachment 349608
This is a 137” 8 point whitetail. Those g2s are 12”. People tend to guess high on whitetail scores.View attachment 349609

This says a lot. A lot of people would say this deer is 150"+. Very nice btw.

 

[WildWill]

Mid 130s.

 

[PJ0311]

Here's another from this morning. I'm guessing this one is also not a high scorer due to tine length. I may go back for him if he's still in the area later. For the record, I'm not hung up on score - i just don't know what constitutes a big whitey like I do muleys.

 

[PJ0311]

 

[Nick87]

Here's another from this morning. I'm guessing this one is also not a high scorer due to tine length. I may go back for him if he's still in the area later. For the record, I'm not hung up on score - i just don't know what constitutes a big whitey like I do muleys.
View attachment 349804

120 that'd be pushing it I think.