Gerald Martin
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jul 3, 2009
- Messages
- 8,689
Here's what I think needs to happen in Montana.
Its always best to start at the start and I would say the single most important thing is to establish REAL herd objectives based on science rather than social tolerance of elk. Without that piece, the rest really doesn't matter.
That would be a science based solution. It would also be a political solution since the MT legislature mandates that FWP sets seasons with the goal of reducing elk numbers to “objective”.
Current “Objective” is an arbitrary number without documentation or defensible data.
Herd health in the form of bull/cow ratios and cow/calf ratios from actual counts is a forgotten inconvenience for FWP.
I watched the bull/cow ratio of unit 121 go from 16-18/100 back in the early 2000’s to 6-8/100 today. That includes the spikes that weren’t legal the prior hunting season.
If I or the sub-contractors I hire built houses the way that the legislature and FWP manage wildlife in MT I would have been fired or forced into bankruptcy because of all the lawsuits.
Its always best to start at the start and I would say the single most important thing is to establish REAL herd objectives based on science rather than social tolerance of elk. Without that piece, the rest really doesn't matter.
That would be a science based solution. It would also be a political solution since the MT legislature mandates that FWP sets seasons with the goal of reducing elk numbers to “objective”.
Current “Objective” is an arbitrary number without documentation or defensible data.
Herd health in the form of bull/cow ratios and cow/calf ratios from actual counts is a forgotten inconvenience for FWP.
I watched the bull/cow ratio of unit 121 go from 16-18/100 back in the early 2000’s to 6-8/100 today. That includes the spikes that weren’t legal the prior hunting season.
If I or the sub-contractors I hire built houses the way that the legislature and FWP manage wildlife in MT I would have been fired or forced into bankruptcy because of all the lawsuits.