Hunt Talk Radio - Look for it on your favorite Podcast platform

EOY '24 - What Worked, What Didn't

BackofBeyond

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 2, 2018
Messages
5,669
Location
Caldwellalajara, ID
It's that time of year folks. Although I've got a couple more trips on the docket, it's time to put 2024, and it's equipment, to rest - time to evaluate and plan what's coming up for 2025.

What worked:

Maven RS1.2 2.5-15x44 - I wasn't sure how I'd like a FFP scope, but after some practice and just getting used to it, I actually kind of like it. This scope is solid. While packing out my elk I strapped my rifle to my pack, then took a couple unintentional barrel rolls down the mountain. The type of fall where I'd almost expect my scope to lose zero - nada. Still dead on. I ran it through the gambit this summer, it tracks consistent, returns to zero consistently, glass quality is on par with other more expensive scopes. This one really punches above it's weight class.

Sitka Ambient Hoody - still one of my favorite pieces of clothing, year after year. Insulates when you need it, somehow dumps heat when you're really exert yourself.

Stone Glacier Chilkoot 15 - I bought this one last spring to replace a 15+ year old REI bag and wish I would have done it much sooner. Ample room through the shoulders without it feeling sloppy. I'm a side sleeper and even though it's loose the bag manages to stick with me while rolling from one side to the other. It's "rated" to 15 degrees, and kept me comfortable all the way down and past to that temperature.

What didn't:

Kenetrek Bridger High - I picked these up because I was looking for something lighter and they just aren't for me. Even though they are the regular (not wide) size, they're still to wide for me. By the time I get them laced up tight enough to keep the ball of my foot secure it cuts off all blood flow and my feet go numb. Loosen the laces and my feet slide all over the place. I've tried two different aftermarket insoles and I just can't find a combination that works. For the time being I've been wearing them for chores etc, and will probably work for backpacking trips this summer where I'll be on trail the entire time, but add in any off camber side hilling with them and I'm out.

Leupold SX-4 15-45 Spotter - There's nothing really "wrong" with the spotter. It works for what it is, but after jumping on the NL Pure train, using the spotter is just underwhelming. I've basically stopped carrying it because it's heavy and I don't use it. It'll probably get relegated to "in the truck" glass.
 
I feel like I have fine tuned my gear enough over the last couple years that I was stoked with how almost everything performed.

New this year winner!
IMG_5823.jpeg

Consistent winners:

NL pures
SG pack
SG gators
Fenix headlight
The .308
IMG_5822.jpeg

Losers:

The 09 tundra with the topper leak in NM and the exploded engine in MT it was a rough year. Truck has been upgraded but the 09 will likely get a new engine and be back at it next fall. 🤷‍♂️
 
What worked:
-Lowa Zephyr mid. Light, comfy, minimal break-in, fits my feet well.

-MR pop up 38. I’ll have to baby it to make it last, w/ the company being sold to Yeti Gucci.

-Axil Trackr Blu amplifying ear muffs. Wonderful hearing protection for shooting at game without losing the little sounds. Amplifies barely detectable sound, and sharply muffles everything over 82 dB. Perfect for small game, whitetail, etc. Long battery life on AA’a. Only complaint is it’s difficult to pinpoint the direction of sounds.

What didn’t:
-Lack of dedicated wet weather gear. 33 degrees, snow, and 40 mph wind, I stayed on the move, but to stop is to freeze to death. After that experience I bought Icebreaker medium-heavy merino base layer, & Kryptek Koldo rain suit. Tested in 33 degrees, all-day rain, and low wind. So far so good. I still need wet weather gloves, and don’t know what to get.

-Ladder stands. Too time consuming to relocate to adjust mid-season. I’m looking at a lone wolf or saddle + sticks for a lightweight mobile treestand set-up.
 
What worked from snowy and wet Yukon, through Wyoming October highs and Saskatchewan bitter November lows.

-Zamberlan 960's;
-More wool, the itchy kind! Ol' scratchies just work;
-Helly Hansen rubber rain gear (would've been absolutely miserable in the Yukon without it);
-Innu bearpaw snowshoes with rubber bindings, quiet and easy to slip on in brutal/cold temps; and
-Steger Mukluks.

Edit: @np307 reminded me of the one and only tool that enables me to sit bear baits in the spring; Thermacell. That stuff just f'n works year after year!
 
Last edited:
Worked great:

MR Sawtooth 45. I've had this pack for 4 years and it's absolutely perfect for the way I hunt deer here at home. 3 more deer packed out with it this year.

Squirrel combo - Savage Mkii fv-sr, swfa ultralight, silencerco sparrow. Killed quite a few squirrels and I'm always impressed by just how accurate it is. It's nice to know that anytime I miss, it's because of me.

Ruger American Ranch (5.56). Second year using this rifle for deer. It's really nice having such a short rifle when pushing through thickets. It doesn't really do anything an AR wouldn't but I prefer a bolt gun.

Thermacell. There's just no way I could stand to hunt early season here without it. The effectiveness is almost startling.

Kinda worked:

SWFA 1-4X24. Truthfully, my issue isn't with the scope itself as much as just hunting with a tactical style reticle. I thought a small scope like this would go well on the ruger, but it's really not a great application for it. The big diamond reticle is just aggravating to look at for me. The scope functioned perfectly though.

77gr TMK. Again, this isn't so much a problem of poor performance as much as a problem of preference. I killed 2 deer with these this year and 1 of them had no exit wound or blood trail. Required me to get my dog and put her on the track. Thankfully she found the deer. Only 50 yards from the shot and a grid search definitely would've found it. Internal damage on the deer was great, absolute carnage. I'll at least give these another year but I really want to find some 75gr gold dots to load instead.

Didn't work:

Outdoor edge replaceable blade. I couldn't find this knife for the first deer I killed this year, so I cleaned that one with my trusty havalon. By the second deer, I had found it and I was immediately struck by how terrible the blades are. I dulled 2 quartering a single deer. Rolled the edges on them. Now it's possible that I just have a bad batch of blades, but I can usually clean a couple deer with a havalon before I run into issues.

Braked rifle with no ear pro. I know it's dumb to shoot a rifle with no hearing protection. But I've done it my entire hunting life. I've never experienced any notable effects and things happen way too quickly in the thick woods to try to put ear plugs in or deal with the difficulty in locating sounds that electronic ear pro causes. Well I threw a brake on my Ruger just because I had one laying around. The first deer I shot with it this year absolutely scared me straight. Lost hearing in my left ear for a couple days with ringing continuing for a couple weeks. I was mentally preparing for it to never go away. Thankfully it has. I already have a suppressor on order so it's not a problem moving forward.

That's about all for me. No real adventurous hunting this year.
 
A lot worked in 2024. Not a lot went as planned, but great results and there’s a few items I am thankful for.

Didn’t work:
Kenetrek gaiters continue to annoy me. The middle half is just too loose, resulting in them always wanting to work their way down or shift while hiking uneven terrain. They are durable though, which is why I haven’t replaced them.

Jetboil Flash - was gifted this last Xmas so have packed it around partially out of guilt, and it is totally fine under early fall conditions, but just completely sucks in high wind or extreme cold, which I kind of thought was the whole point.

Worked:
Old Faithfuls:
Crispi Lapponias
AGC bino harness
Sig range finder
Meopta Meopro 10x42s
Hornady 120 gr CX

Newer items:
Agree with @BackofBeyond, I love the Sitka Ambient jacket, my favorite mid/outer layer.

Splurged for an Ollin system for my 60x spotter which I have enjoyed playing around with.
IMG_6147.jpeg

Hilleberg Enan. Lighter than any other free standing tent I own, yet more durable as well (with the exception of another Hilleberg). Being 6’4” it’s a little tight, but when I break it out I’m not expecting a spacious palace, it just does its job, and I had some conditions in the alpine that put it to the test.
IMG_4883.jpeg


Spartan Javelin Lite bipod. This thing is sweet. So light and functional. I do not rifle hunt without it in my pocket now. I think I’d probably like the Pro even more, but don’t know what I’m missing.
IMG_6186.jpeg

Little Kowa TSN501 20-40x spotter on an Amazon basics tripod. Shit on it all you want, but Jeff Bezos is a guy who clearly understands backcountry hunting needs, and this combo weighs next to nothing (the scope is 14.5 oz) and is my go-to for lightweight hunts. Obviously the panhead sucks but stable enough to get a good view on stationary animals.
IMG_5813.jpeg
IMG_5815.jpeg

Last and probably most significant change for me this season: hunting with friends. 75+% of my hunting prior to this season was solo. Prior to this season I had only ever killed and packed out elk by myself. In contrast, this year I had help on 2 elk packouts, 3 people helped on my goat hunt, will have 2 more friends helping on a coues hunt in a couple weeks, and I was also able to tag along on another goat hunt as well as help on an elk packout. I will always love solo hunting and will never give that up, but I really enjoyed and am grateful for my time with friends in the mountains this year and hope to have more balance between the two in the future.
 
I hadn’t owned any Stone Glacier stuff prior to this season and think I’ve been missing out.

Bought their bino harness and all the accoutrements from another member on here. It’s the superior system on the market right now. Love it.

Also loved their DeHavilland pants. The adjustable waistband is a game changer. Felt magical to not have if my drawers riding up and around all day.

Also have to shout out to the calcium channel blockers prescribed by my PCP. I used to get some painful Reynauds attacks in cold weather when I’d stop to glass, no matter how well I’d insulate myself. Was able to hang in full comfort this year.
 
Worked:
Eberlestock day pack with the built in scabbard it is so slick for carrying a rifle
Schnees Beartooth on Season 3 or 4
Kuiu Bino Harness - no magnets to mess with compass, cool ammo wallet that attaches out of the way and easy attach/detach bear spray on bottom
Trusty Browning X-bolt Hells Canyon Speed in 6.5 PRC
Sitka Core Lightweight and Apex Hoodies - are awesome separate but worn together they tame cold weather and shed heat pretty well. The built in facemasks are amazing as well.
Kuiu Softshell jacket - my new go-to wear every time jacket
Vortex Fury rangefinding Binos probably 4-5 years old
Mystery Ranch Metcalf, still my go-to if I have to pack out game
Caribou Wapiti set of game bags - bomb proof and use over and over again
15 year old Mountain hardware packable Down coat - lifesaver adds zero weight to pack
3/4 length Sitka down glassing pants - pretty comfy

Didn't work:
My navigation and map reading skills
Schnees Timberlines - 2nd leaky pair in a row
Old aluminum tripod - hard to pan, jerky movements. had to replace, got a Sirui at suggestion of folks on here and I'm digging it so far, pretty smooth
Magview - kind of garbage have to re-aim everytime, meh
 
Braked rifle with no ear pro. I know it's dumb to shoot a rifle with no hearing protection. But I've done it my entire hunting life. I've never experienced any notable effects and things happen way too quickly in the thick woods to try to put ear plugs in or deal with the difficulty in locating sounds that electronic ear pro causes. Well I threw a brake on my Ruger just because I had one laying around. The first deer I shot with it this year absolutely scared me straight. Lost hearing in my left ear for a couple days with ringing continuing for a couple weeks. I was mentally preparing for it to never go away. Thankfully it has. I already have a suppressor on order so it's not a problem moving forward.

That's about all for me. No real adventurous hunting this year.
Likely the ear damage will eventually come home to roost forever. Be patient and plan to regret choices made for the long term. And, no, things do not happen way to quickly in the woods to apply ear protection. But some guys erroneously think getting a quick shot is more important than taking a moment for ear protection ...
 
Yea:
Marsupial Upland Vest. I am tired of full vests. Crappy zippers. Way too hot chasing sharptails. Not enough customizable storage. Limited hydration pack options. This was waaaaaaay better. Got Hunting Husband a Final Rise last year for Christmas. They seem pretty similar, though I like the low-profile strap option in the Marsupial for myself.

Nay:
My tag drawing luck.

My bow release. The shop had limited options when I bought it a couple years ago. The smallest one they had was a TruFire, so that’s what I got. Now I did manage to kill my first archery animal this year, so maybe it isn’t a big deal….but it squeaks so freaking bad, it drives me nuts. Looking to get something else before next year.
 
Worked:
The new muzzleloader setup worked well.
CVA Wolf V2 50 Cal.
Barnes 50 Cal 250 grain T-EZ sabots pushed by 110 grain (by volume) BH209. Shot two deer with them last week. Great performance on both.
Went with an UltraDot Gen 1 red dot sight on the muzzy. I am very happy with it. Got it on eBay for a great price. I'd imagine the newer ones are as good or better.
Rossi Tuffy Turkey .410 was awesome during turkey season. Great little gun. Plenty of knockdown power with the Federal TSS shells I swore I'd never buy... (I'll eat a little bit of crow on this. TSS is worth it for a .410, but wouldn't pay for it shooting a 20 or 12.
Havalon Piranta. Did my wife's entire cow gutless method with 1 blade. Blade was still nice and sharp at the end. I've always liked this knife. Great knife if you take your time and you're not a hack with it.
Break Free CLP. Great all around lube, especially when temps start to dip.


Didn't work:
Big Buddy propane heater crapped out on a cold December night.
My attitude while I hunt alone. Poor attitude shortened a couple hunts when things got slightly off the rails.
 
Likely the ear damage will eventually come home to roost forever. Be patient and plan to regret choices made for the long term. And, no, things do not happen way to quickly in the woods to apply ear protection. But some guys erroneously think getting a quick shot is more important than taking a moment for ear protection ...
Did you read the rest of the paragraph? I admitted that it was dumb, I was sharing what I believe is a very common mindset that others have and what I'm doing to address it. I'm talking about thick eastern woodlands where shot opportunities happen under 50 yards and the time between deer detection to shot opportunity to no more shot opportunity is usually under 30 seconds.

Edit: just to be clear, because I reread my original text and it isn't clear, I have always worn ear pro when target shooting.
 
Last edited:
Did you read the rest of the paragraph? I admitted that it was dumb, I was sharing what I believe is a very common mindset that others have and what I'm doing to address it. I'm talking about thick eastern woodlands where shot opportunities happen under 50 yards and the time between deer detection to shot opportunity to no more shot opportunity is usually under 30 seconds.
For this that suppressor will change your life! I wouldn’t say I refuse to shoot without one, but I’d rather not.
 
MTNTOUGH - Use promo code RANDY for 30 days free

Forum statistics

Threads
113,946
Messages
2,038,760
Members
36,405
Latest member
208hntr
Back
Top