Similar experience, those Nittos are great for the pavement princess trucks tho. You won’t regret the coopers, the st pros are good tooCurrently have a set of nitto ridgegrapplers on my work pickup. Have had 5 flats in 8500miles and two of the 5 the tire has need replaced because of the size of the hole. Putting a new set on tomorrow of Cooper Discover ST Maxx. Have them on my personal pickup and they have been great in the snow and ice