Caribou Gear Tarp

NM Unit 51 December Muzzleloader - what to expect?

MDW

New member
Joined
Oct 2, 2023
Messages
14
Hey HTers

I am a newbie Hunt Talker here and so far have appreciated everything this community is about. I was hoping maybe someone has had this either sex, early December tag before and would be willing to share their experience. I live in southern Colorado so the unit is about three hours from me, affording me the ability to go scout. I went last weekend and got into some elk in a northern area of 51A that I had e-scouted. It was around 9500ft and was amazing elk country, but not necessarily the country I would normally hunt in December in Northern CO, where I am used to hunting. It was "probably" accessible by 4x4 with chains, even if there is some snow.

While it was great to see elk right away, I am still hesitant if that is the right elevation range for December, and I think that my primary zone will be dependent on snow depths, but maybe not - maybe the elk start herding up anyways? I see from the SNOTEL stations in the area that there could be no snow to a foot of snow by the first week of December.

I am not looking for specific spots or anything but curious if anyone has hunted this season or if anyone living in the area can speak to how quickly the elk migrate when the snow comes, if it does. Area 51B looks like it has good potential if the animals have migrated since it is lower PJ. Any insight would be much appreciated.

Looking forward to hearing more stories from this year and thanks in advance. Also, if anyone would like more detail on my scouting trip I am happy to share. I drove down the middle of 51A from top to bottom. It was damn rough but nothing too bad since roads were dry. Beautiful elk country the whole way and also saw quite a few turkeys. Hoping to check out 51B next weekend.

-Mike

Night 1 Camp where elk were bugling from every direction
1696606411946.png



Looking SE towards from the top of Jose Maria Canyon
1696606343845.png
 
Mike, How did your hunt go? How was the snow/weather and roads?
I drew 51 December elk muzzleloader this year and live in Minnesota so will not be able to get any scouting in but will get there a few days early.
Did you tent, camper, cabin/hotel?
any info is appreciated.
thank you phil
 
Hey HTers

I am a newbie Hunt Talker here and so far have appreciated everything this community is about. I was hoping maybe someone has had this either sex, early December tag before and would be willing to share their experience. I live in southern Colorado so the unit is about three hours from me, affording me the ability to go scout. I went last weekend and got into some elk in a northern area of 51A that I had e-scouted. It was around 9500ft and was amazing elk country, but not necessarily the country I would normally hunt in December in Northern CO, where I am used to hunting. It was "probably" accessible by 4x4 with chains, even if there is some snow.

While it was great to see elk right away, I am still hesitant if that is the right elevation range for December, and I think that my primary zone will be dependent on snow depths, but maybe not - maybe the elk start herding up anyways? I see from the SNOTEL stations in the area that there could be no snow to a foot of snow by the first week of December.

I am not looking for specific spots or anything but curious if anyone has hunted this season or if anyone living in the area can speak to how quickly the elk migrate when the snow comes, if it does. Area 51B looks like it has good potential if the animals have migrated since it is lower PJ. Any insight would be much appreciated.

Looking forward to hearing more stories from this year and thanks in advance. Also, if anyone would like more detail on my scouting trip I am happy to share. I drove down the middle of 51A from top to bottom. It was damn rough but nothing too bad since roads were dry. Beautiful elk country the whole way and also saw quite a few turkeys. Hoping to check out 51B next weekend.

-Mike

Night 1 Camp where elk were bugling from every direction
View attachment 295550



Looking SE towards from the top of Jose Maria Canyon

Hey HTers

I am a newbie Hunt Talker here and so far have appreciated everything this community is about. I was hoping maybe someone has had this either sex, early December tag before and would be willing to share their experience. I live in southern Colorado so the unit is about three hours from me, affording me the ability to go scout. I went last weekend and got into some elk in a northern area of 51A that I had e-scouted. It was around 9500ft and was amazing elk country, but not necessarily the country I would normally hunt in December in Northern CO, where I am used to hunting. It was "probably" accessible by 4x4 with chains, even if there is some snow.

While it was great to see elk right away, I am still hesitant if that is the right elevation range for December, and I think that my primary zone will be dependent on snow depths, but maybe not - maybe the elk start herding up anyways? I see from the SNOTEL stations in the area that there could be no snow to a foot of snow by the first week of December.

I am not looking for specific spots or anything but curious if anyone has hunted this season or if anyone living in the area can speak to how quickly the elk migrate when the snow comes, if it does. Area 51B looks like it has good potential if the animals have migrated since it is lower PJ. Any insight would be much appreciated.

Looking forward to hearing more stories from this year and thanks in advance. Also, if anyone would like more detail on my scouting trip I am happy to share. I drove down the middle of 51A from top to bottom. It was damn rough but nothing too bad since roads were dry. Beautiful elk country the whole way and also saw quite a few turkeys. Hoping to check out 51B next weekend.

-Mike

Night 1 Camp where elk were bugling from every direction
View attachment 295550



Looking SE towards from the top of Jose Maria Canyon
View attachment 295549
Drew new mexico 51 dec muzzleloader this year and would like to know anything you would be willing to share about the weather camping and everything else.
I also drew colorado 80/81 archery elk.
 
Last edited:
Drew new mexico 51 dec muzzleloader this year and would like to know anything you would be willing to share about the weather camping and everything else.
I also drew colorado 80/81 archery elk.
[email protected]
I’m going to kill the mature bull in the unit in mid October. I’m told they all get killed during the early season but I’m gonna find the lone hold out. Sorry man!
 
I drew the December muzzy hunt as well if anyone who drew wants to chat feel free to PM.
 
if you have a sxs or 4wheeler I would strongly recommend taking it.
I’ve heard roads are rough right now. For this hunt I’m looking lower and bachelor groups for bulls. I scouted summer and found cows but really think moving is going to be key. Never hunted there so very excited!
 
if you have a sxs or 4wheeler I would strongly recommend taking it.
I have a side by side, most curious if they are going to be down on the BLM or up on the NF which I suppose depends on how much snow there is.
 
Kenetrek Boots

Forum statistics

Threads
114,013
Messages
2,041,130
Members
36,430
Latest member
Dusky
Back
Top