Input Needed to Make the Show Yellowstone More Authentic

[NR_Hunter]

I love how all these places treat their employees like dogs and then act like it’s an honor to work on their ranch

 

[44hunter45]

Make it water world - hear me out - but on a ranch.

No No - The Postman

The only thing Tom Petty did that I liked.

 

[2rocky]

+1 to the comment about a Winter on the ranch...Yet...Not a Stormy Kromer to be seen... or a stack yard of hay...

 

[44hunter45]

Google Taylor Sheridan....

I loved both "Wind River" and "Hell or High Water". Reading here I'm thinking "Yellowstone" is not his best work?

 

[CowboyLeroy]

Less chronic application of the f word

 

[Tradewind]

I watched about 1/2 hour of it and cost me half of my limited supply of brain cells. Best I could tell it is the Montana version of the show "Dallas" with equal bad acting and a few f-bombs. None of the scheming women in it come close to being as good looking as Victoria Principal, however.

all that from justt 1/2 hour?

 

[SaskHunter]

More Stormy Kromers, more Carhartt, more fat cowboys, more handlebar moustaches, a few mullets, less fancy horse stuff/dressage, etc.

They're also playing lots of Colter Wall, a Sasky boy, on this season which is alright.

 

[Tradewind]

I may be sticking my head in a hornets nest but here goes: Yes, they show hard horn deer and elk in the spring/summer and yup - the cowboys wear way too new and not worn out too clean clothes and no, there is not a chance in hell that ball cap Jimmy could win any rodeo event - EVER, Monica is Asian, not Native American, the main house is way too fancy, no rancher I know flies a helicopter or has a personal chef, and they leave a good number of loose ends around each season - but - I love this show! Beth is a smart, gorgeous bad ass, Rip is very believable, Jamie is one of the best/worst weasels ever, Costner plays the Godfather of Montana pretty well and they actually get to kill people who need killing (OK - some of them didn't really deserve it). And, no, I'm not from Montana, I don't own a ranch nor have I ever roped anything, so what do I know?

Just my humble .02. Please leave a little meat on my bones. If it helps, I don't own a helicopter, a Raptor, or anything made by Sitka or KUIU

i agree

 

[mtmuley]

I love it. Drives up my property value. Bring it. mtmuley

 

[Tradewind]

Rip, Kayce, or John allowing the sloots in the bunkhouse doesn’t reconcile.

You need some gratuitous sex to keep the rest of the critics on here interested

 

[Tradewind]

What I like is that the people who live on the coasts think that is actually how life is in MT

 

[Nick87]

I love it. Drives up my property value. Bring it. mtmuley

You'd trade property values for mass exodus in a heartbeat.

 

[noharleyyet]

Who doesn't fistfight better after being stabbed to the hilt in the upper chest...

 

[Nick87]

Who doesn't fistfight better after being stabbed to the hilt in the upper chest...

The day after...I know where I'd of been aiming.

 

[NR_Hunter]

It was so funny when that old business lady was talking about making Montana the next Colorado. I think I heard the collective jaw clenching of all Montanans all the way over here in MN.

 

[MarvB]

The wife watches it so I do catch bits and pieces…had to laugh on Sunday, I was down the hall putting/cleaning the vacuum back together and heard the exchange between “Beth” and whoever the gal is that her dad had taken home. I walked back in the front room, looked at the wife, and said (again I’m the father of three girls) “that’s a discussion I’ve never had with my children ”!

Potty mouth much??

 

[2rocky]

A lot of metaphors about Canines and Beth's character are very eerily accurate. Good and Bad.

 

[noharleyyet]

Beth could make Andrew Dice Clay blanch..

 

[2rocky]

Texas loves Taylor Sheridan...They put him in their Cowboy Hall of Fame....

 

[MO Betta]

I've only watched a few episodes, stopped after the livestock agent swat team episodes. Grew up farming and raising cattle, Rip reminded me of more than a couple hands I worked with. The rest of it, well, it is a TV show after all.