At some point - I knew we would agree. The effort and $ used to change names...
"English" bird names, "Offensive or Exclusionary" to change.
- Thread starter Sytes
- Start date
I doubt it. I doubt you could find more than a handful of people anywhere that know anything about 95% of the people the birds were named after. Let alone care. Birds aren't named after famous people in order to somehow honor them. Birds are named after the person who first discovered them and reported the discovery to whoever it is that somehow has the authority to name birds.
Even the people doing the name change admit it isn't because the names are in any way offensive, but rather that someone, somewhere, sometime, for some reason might object to the person the bird was named after and they don't want to deal with that nonsense.
trackerbacker
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jun 30, 2023
- Messages
- 464
It is sarcasm, and satire, but I agree, tell them rednecks that it's stars and stripes, not that pussy-ass naval flag bars and scars or whatever they parade.
It's America. American flag first.
The Confederate? Absolutely. American flag first, front and God damn center. State next. The rest can go elsewhere, anywhere else, I don't care.
Of American history? No, I clearly stated such. The civil war, was fought predominantly by Americans, and as such, obviously, is American history, and any stains and gains should remain, but the losers, whiners and freaks should be put in their place.
Quite simple
Keep the discussion to bird names and drop the race baiting bullshit that is going to get this thread locked.
D
Deleted member 28227
Guest
Don’t disagree at all more just pointing out the superficial interest for most on topics like these.
“There is power in a name, and some English bird names have associations with the past that continue to be exclusionary and harmful today."
This has to be one of the most imbecilic reasons for the organization to change names. Superficially asinine.
I know many of us are involved in "conservation" efforts... So park the b.s. whines of declared dues required to be paid to speak our thoughts on a public forum.
Next up, "Roosevelt" elk?
John Muir founder of the Sierra Club...
Winter Wren, rogolodytes troglodytes muiri
"The first bird named in honor of John Muir, whose life's work of conservation has helped protect the redwood habitat of this wren."
Audubon's Shearwater, Puffinus lherminieri
"Audubon’s Shearwater and Audubon’s Oriole honor renowned avian artist John James Audubon"
Address misdeeds, if necessary, though do not dispose the good of humankind.
This has to be one of the most imbecilic reasons for the organization to change names. Superficially asinine.
I know many of us are involved in "conservation" efforts... So park the b.s. whines of declared dues required to be paid to speak our thoughts on a public forum.
Next up, "Roosevelt" elk?
John Muir founder of the Sierra Club...
Winter Wren, rogolodytes troglodytes muiri
"The first bird named in honor of John Muir, whose life's work of conservation has helped protect the redwood habitat of this wren."
Audubon's Shearwater, Puffinus lherminieri
"Audubon’s Shearwater and Audubon’s Oriole honor renowned avian artist John James Audubon"
Address misdeeds, if necessary, though do not dispose the good of humankind.
BuzzH
Well-known member
I would like to see the names change to be more descriptive of the birds to help identify them.
Don't care beyond that.
Don't care beyond that.
VikingsGuy
Well-known member
Sorry, but . . .
Yet - here you are posting about not giving a #$%&. Find your life if you do not give...
BuzzH
Well-known member
Well that's true, but things like blue and green winged teal are pretty descriptive. Ruffed grouse, white fronted geese, pintail, gray crowned rosy finch, etc etc etc.
Common names that help describe the birds is pretty handy, and smart, imo. Same with plants.
Nerd.
On a humor note... Anyone recall this SNL skit? Had to find it for chits n grins... It's relevant in some way, shape, or feather.
Best response yet. Gets beyond the "debate" and to the meat and potatoes of the topic. And, it's Buzz. No shit talk, berating sarcasm, etc... Feel as though I've entered aTwilight Zone episode.
I think this would be a great use of the common bird name.
Likely not in agreement with some here (surprised? ) though maintain the scientific name tributes, such as, rogolodytes troglodytes muiri (Winter Wren) - named in honor of John Muir for his immense conservation efforts that has kept much of what we we value present.
Best response yet. Gets beyond the "debate" and to the meat and potatoes of the topic. And, it's Buzz. No shit talk, berating sarcasm, etc... Feel as though I've entered aTwilight Zone episode.
I think this would be a great use of the common bird name.
Likely not in agreement with some here (surprised?
) though maintain the scientific name tributes, such as, rogolodytes troglodytes muiri (Winter Wren) - named in honor of John Muir for his immense conservation efforts that has kept much of what we we value present.Then there's my favorite, the "Double Breasted Bed Thrasher."
But I'm sure some idiot will probably declare that to be too offensive.
"Red-headed Double-breasted Mattress-Thrasher" or so some claim... Hah!
I followed the rabbit hole to find the scientific name for such only to wander the red light district of the... internet.
During my search I came across this fine "scientific" placard for birds.
