Elk are Deer

[Washington Hunter]

Good point...if A minus B does not equal zero then A does not equal B. Therefore an elk is not a deer. TB what do you think? Do you remember algebra from high school?

 

[Tom]

Oh, are, not and.

That second word threw me. Moose is the biggest deer, they say. I guess, elk are deer, why do you care? Its the scientific stuff, cervids or something.

cervus elk, cervus whitetail What's the point?

 

[danr55]

You guys have just gotten the symbols transposed. A does equal B by A is an Elk and B is a deer. Therefore, A-B does equal 0 becuase you can't go into negative weight with objects of mass.

All A's are B's but not all B's are A's. Some B's are C(aribou)'s and some B's are M(oose)'s. (and this is all a lot of BM).. Therefore, A always equals B, but B is not always equal to A.

Is that clearer?

 

[Washington Hunter]

Clear as mud...

 

[Nut]

I always thought that does are female deer and cows are female elk.

 

[BinBandB4]

But Cows are beef, and deer are venison, so venison can't be beef so deer aren't elk, but they might be salmon because some people think you can lump anything into salmon despite it not being salmon.

 

[danr55]

You see there.. A Gummer by any other name still gets smarter.. He is absolutely right. Not all deer are elk, but all elk are deer... It's just like tuna and Mackeral.. Not all makeral are tuna but all tuna are makeral.. so are jacks... but none of these are salmon..

 

[Ten Bears]

BBB4, but can you prove that steelhead aren't salmon on the correct thread. DANR, you got it.

 

[danr55]

10Bears.. Can I get shots for it? I bet I caught it from a lawyer, too....

 

[Ten Bears]

I think it can be cured..... Lots of fluids was the last I heard......

 

[BinBandB4]

Ten Beers,

Please refute that Elk are not Salmon.

 

[ELKCHSR]

???? Now who isn't making any sense and needs an interpreter!

 

[Ten Bears]

Ten Beers,

Please refute that Elk are not Salmon.

That is good....

BBB4, why don't you smoke less hay free weed when your posting.

 

[BinBandB4]

Ten,

Struggling to stay on topic, and now just resorting to personal attacks?

If you haven't noticed, this entire thread is homage to your struggles in reasoning... hump

 

[Ten Bears]

Ten,

Struggling to stay on topic, and now just resorting to personal attacks?

If you haven't noticed, this entire thread is homage to your struggles in reasoning... hump

Struggling to stay on topic??? I agreed with the topic.

Resorting to personal attacks???? No, more then your third grade comments. Next you'll be claiming you don't smoke at all.

I understand this thread is an homage to your inability to comprehend a topic. hump hump

 

[BinBandB4]

Ten Beers,

Please inform us all the point of this topic, if it was not to make fun of you?

 

[Ten Bears]

BBB4, elk are deer, steelhead are salmon, and any that would attack another for stating so is just being nonsensical. I see this thread as poking a finger at the nonsensical attacks and nonsensical reasoning used in those attacks. So, I therefore agree with the topic; elk are deer, and your attacks otherwise are nonsense. If I am incorrect, I would hope that GH would correct me, and keep me on topic.

 

[MattK]

Well, this year I'll be using my deer tag for that bull elk as an elk is a deer. Then I think I will buy a salmon tag for the rainbow salmon that I catch. When a game warden asks wtf I think I am doing I will make mention of the "trout are salmon board" and the "elk are deer" posts. I'm sure it will certainly explain it all crystal clear to those wardens who don't possess the same common sense as those on this board do.

 

[Michaelr]

matt, your silly

 

[Ithaca 37]

michael, Thanks for posting. Now you're on "Ignore" just like Ten Bears and BHR.