Butcher Buck P&Y #2

[MarvB]

Butcher Buck Is Officially the No. 2 Non-Typical Whitetail Bow Kill of All Time; Crazy only 3 scorable points on one side, 64 on the other

 

[Flatbrimmer]

67 point buck test it like they did Barry Bonds…….

 

[Wildabeest]

How the hell do you score that thing?

 

[Hilljackoutlaw]

How the hell do you score that thing?

Guess and write down the number. What a nightmare.

 

[MarvB]

I read that it took the panel over five hours to score (and agree) it.
No thank you

 

[rogerthat]

Trash head…that thing is hideous.

 

[Flatbrimmer]

Is it me or that driftwood leaning way to the left to counter-balance??

 

[TrumpkinTheDwarf]

I think I'd rather shoot a nice typical 10 pt with good mass and tines than that thing. I don't think I'd trust the meat. Looks like a Chernobyl buck!

 

[Little Big Man MT Chris]

I think I'd rather shoot a nice typical 10 pt with good mass and tines than that thing. I don't think I'd trust the meat. Looks like a Chernobyl buck!

Exactly, That buck was feeding in some field where the meth heads were dumping all their chemicals

 

[appaloosa]

Yep, a truly unremarkable deer that benefitted from an imperfect scoring system.

 

[bobbydean]

Would any of the members talking trash about the deer turn it down!

That deer is spectacular!

 

[TrumpkinTheDwarf]

Would any of the members talking trash about the deer turn it down!

That deer is spectacular!

I wouldn't turn it down. But I've shot plenty of bambi's when I'd prefer a monster. I can simultaneously say "eww, gross..." and pull the trigger. Maybe I've just got mad skills!

 

[Little Big Man MT Chris]

Would any of the members talking trash about the deer turn it down!

That deer is spectacular!

Like Trumpkin said , I’d shoot it too , but it’s not a kind of buck I dream about , I’ll still talk trash about a buck that’s got more trash than my local dump , that buck is just ugly. But then again each of us have different ideas or dreams of what a great buck is.

 

[appaloosa]

Like Trumpkin said , I’d shoot it too , but it’s not a kind of buck I dream about , I’ll still talk trash about a buck that’s got more trash than my local dump , that buck is just ugly. But then again each of us have different ideas or dreams of what a great buck is.

^ This.
Nothing against the thing, I would shoot it too. But, when I dream of world-class deer, the kind that sit atop the record books, a 3-pt with mistletoe growing out one side of its head isn't one of them.

 

[RobertD]

I was too chickenshit to post this at first, but since others agree I'll come out and say it: It's disappointing to me that that buck is considered a world-class animal.

 

[Nick87]

I was too chickenshit to post this at first, but since others agree I'll come out and say it: It's disappointing to me that that buck is considered a world-class animal.

Scoring system doesnt always do justice, that goes both ways.

 

[TheTone]

I absolutely would have shot it but not sure I would have thought to have it scored being as non typical and small framed as it seems

 

[Gary]

No doubt, it would take the Gold in any "UGLY BUCK" contest. Would I shoot it - probably. Would I shoot IF a 160 ten pointer was standing next to it? Damned if I know, but not a question I'm gonna lose sleep over.
Question - would it be considered as ugly if the right side matched the left??? Or would that make it even uglier?

 

[SC Living Outdoors]

Man, that is an ugly deer. lol

 

[Nick87]

Would I shoot IF a 160 ten pointer was standing next to it?

Nope I'd got for the 160, shoot right over his back and there I'd be.