Little Canyon Creek
Active member
Grayling is on my bucket list. Can't seem to find them in lakes around here.
Like Ajax said, you should really try Joe Wright Reservoir. It isn't a secret, but it is a lot of fun. Bring a canoe or a float tube. This lake was the reason why my dad ended up getting a canoe. There are a lot of grayling in there. Not the biggest, but I remember them getting bigger (10-12") after they added some female Lake Trout to control their numbers. The very first time I fished there I caught a cutthroat that must have washed down from the lake that feeds Joe Wright Creek, but I don't think there are hardly any in there.
If you fly fish, we have sometimes run into big hatches where there are fish hitting on top everywhere. Other times there aren't any hatches happening and you have to work a little. Last summer I tied on some pheasant tail nymphs and a thingamabobber when nothing was happening up top. I ended up doing pretty well. We have also had success with panther martins, though I would snip off two of the hooks off the treble. Their mouths are small and if you get more than one hook in their mouth it is difficult to get them out.
The biggest grayling I have caught have all been in Montana. I didn't catch a lot of them, but I did catch three that were 16-17". They were some of the prettiest fish I have ever caught, with a beautiful purple bronze hues and their famous fins. They are one of my favorite fish to catch, and I hope the restoration efforts in Montana continue.