Search results
-
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
One last point @sclancy27 why did the late 40s and 50s kick out so many big bucks in Montana? Agreed but to insinuate buck genetics play no part is pretty hard for me to believe. I had never seen a drop tine buck in my life. In 2015 I found an area that had a drop tine buck. I have now seen... -
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
Not to mention why do private ranch deer owners pay ridiculous amounts for the breeder sires? Why do they care if it’s not genetics? I’m not arguing montieths research(I listen to all the cokslide podcasts) but even they would admit their research is still developing. I will bet money they... -
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
How can you be sure about that? Can you link a study? -
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
Sean, I’m not buying the habitat=big antlers simply because with the right genetics a whitetail(ranch buck) is over 200 as a 2.5 year old. The same thing happens in the wild. The big ones are big when they are young based on my anecdotal experience. That jives with @antlerradar explanation -
-
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
You think big antlers are just statistically random? I think big antlers are an expression of that bucks viability. Typically they have big bodies and are the dominant buck.(not always but more likely statistically) -
MT Mule Deer Age data accuracy and reality
Well if you mounted them they must have been good. Skewing those results to the low end 😂 -
Pack out pics
- rogerthat
- Post #262
- Forum: Fireside (A Place for Friends)
-
Jordan Peterson interview
I literally don’t know a single person any of you dorks have named.- rogerthat
- Post #8
- Forum: Fireside (A Place for Friends)
-
The Governor, the Wolf and the Warden: A Fresh Look at a Gianforte Hunt
Another positive, the governor of our state traps and hunts. I’m liking that a lot better than what Colorado has going on but I agree the way Loewen went out needs more explanation. Hopefully it wasn’t retaliation as insinuated.- rogerthat
- Post #20
- Forum: Sportsmen Issues
-
Anyone else been kicked off rocks lied?
More importantly, whatcha do?- rogerthat
- Post #2
- Forum: Fireside (A Place for Friends)
-
Shank it? or Crank it? Only the Billy knows
Following- rogerthat
- Post #14
- Forum: BIG THREE - Moose, Goat, Sheep
-
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
In Montana we have unit permits for a critter but an unlimited quota of them are issued. So basically you get the permit if you apply for it. -
-
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
I think I finally understand where you’re coming from @Shed God and the general vicinity of where you hunt. I have spent some days in that general area 20 plus years ago. To me it emphasizes how a single season structure for a state the size of Montana is always going to fall short. -
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
Do the elk not get pushed around with the current season process where you hunt? Honestly trying to wrap my mind around your situation. Edit: are you killing your mature bulls early or late currently? -
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
Count me in😂. Those are incredible sheds for Montana. I’m not the one you need to convince to go limited entry. Like you my primary focus is big racks. Unfortunately we aren’t the norm. -
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
Yeah I think we would need good hunter days data per region. It just doesn’t exist. -
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
Don’t you think experienced hunters have some idea what is going to happen when changes are proposed? For example let’s use Colorado pushing their season dates a week later. We knew this was going to make the bigger older more mature bucks more vulnerable to harvest right? And it did. To... -
Montana General Season Structure Proposal
General season wyoming units. Guns are a blazing at the deer and the bulls are bugling. To be accurate, I said he makes assumptions that I THINK are wrong. I stand by that statement. I think he is wrong with his assumptions. 1). Deer hunting pressure does not equal elk hunting pressure...
