Frankin Muley

[The Hedgehog]

Awesome buck. It's a non-typical, with no G-3 on either side. Your H3 is taken halfway up the 1st tall point on each side, and so on..

https://pope-young.org/images/uploads/files/scoreforms/2012_PY_SS_WEB_DEER_MULE_BLK_NON_TYP.pdf

 

[Duck-Slayer]

Interesting.... Thought it was pretty typical?
Matt

 

[antlerradar]

inside spread 29 Duck-slayer
MB 27 2/8 Greenhorn
G1 6 2/8 Greenhorn
G2 20 4/8 Antlerradar
G3 13 6/8 Antlerradar
G4 13 6/8 Greenhorn
H1 6 0/8 Antlerradar/ Duck-slayer
H2 5 4/8 Duck-slayer
H3 4 3/8 Greenhorn
H4 5 7/8 Duck- slayer
NT 21 3/8 Antlerradar, Looks like Duck-slayer could have more

Score 103 2/8 x 2 = 206 4/8 +27 2/8 spread credit = 233 6/8 typical
Nontypical 233 6/8 typical + 21 3/8 nontypical = 255 1/8 NT

 

[psinclair]

My 1991 Idaho buck has a few good inches.....grin! Officially scored, and entered in 1992.

Left MB: 28 1/8"
Right G3: 14 2/8"
Left G2: 21 3/8"

 

[1_pointer]

My 1991 Idaho buck has a few good inches.....grin! Officially scored, and entered in 1992.

Left MB: 28 1/8"
Right G3: 14 2/8"
Left G2: 21 3/8"

That is, IMO, one of the best field pics of a great buck. Congrats on both!

 

[Festus]

That is, IMO, one of the best field pics of a great buck. Congrats on both!

Yes!! Awesome picture! Truly awesome buck!

 

[antlerradar]

psinclair, I knew that buck would add some inches.

inside spread 29 0/8 duckslayer
MB 28 1/8 psinclair
G1 6 2/8 Greenhorn
G2 21 3/8 psinclair
G3 14 2/8 psinclair
G4 13 6/8 Greenhorn
H1 6 0/8 Antlerradar/ duckslayer
H2 5 4/8 duckslayer
H3 4 3/8 Greenhorn
H4 5 7/8 duckslayer

total 105 4/8

nontypical 21 3/8 antlerradar

Score 105 4/8 x 2 = 211+ 28 1/8 spread credit =239 1/8


Nontypical score 239 1/8 + 21 3/8 = 260 4/8

 

[poormanslam]

Not a lot of help but a little. The first picture is a SW Mt buck one of the first I was in on: 14 4/8 G4.

The second buck, my best, is a eastern Idaho buck with 29 3/8 non-typical inches.

 

[antlerradar]

inside spread 29 0/8 duckslayer
mainbeam 28 1/8 psinclair
G1 6 2/8 Greenhorn
G2 21 3/8 psinclair
G3 14 2/8 psinclair
G4 14 4/8 poormanslam
H1 6 0/8 Antlerradar/ duckslayer
H2 5 4/8 duckslayer
H3 4 3/8 Greenhorn
H4 5 7/8 duckslayer

total 106 0/8

Nontypical 29 3/8 poormanslam

Score 106x2 = 212 + 28 1/8 spread credit = 240 1/8 typical

240 1/8 + 29 3/8 = 269 4/8 nontypical

Less that 10 inches to go for 250 typical.

Antlerradar

 

[The Hedgehog]

Will have an updated inside spread measurement from my son's 2016 MT buck. Official measurer is stopping by this weekend to measure antelope, and I suspect he'll get the same as me 30-1/2" inside.

 

[teamhoyt]

Daughters 2016 buck. 32" of extras

 

[Big Billy]

great buck 28" main beam wow..lokks like salmon river country?

 

[kmf]

Just think how much bigger your bucks would be if the Minnesota guys didn't shoot all the 2 year old 3x3s.

 

[Big Fin]

I get H1 measurements of 6 2/8 and 6 0/8 on my NV buck from this year, but not knowing crap about official scoring the odds are an official measurer would get half of that.

 

[antlerradar]

I get H1 measurements of 6 2/8 and 6 0/8 on my NV buck from this year, but not knowing crap about official scoring the odds are an official measurer would get half of that.

H1 is pretty straight forward on your buck. Smallest place between the burr and the browtine using a 1/4 inch steel tape. I have seen people use a plastic sewing tape. That will inflate the measurement a good amount. After going back and looking at your NV buck I can see 6 inch + H1's

 

[antlerradar]

Just think how much bigger your bucks would be if the Minnesota guys didn't shoot all the 2 year old 3x3s.

Not to hijack my own thread but have to disagree. Montana has difficulty growing big deer not because we shoot a lot of 2 year old 3x3's. but because we shoot nearly all the nice bucks. Clearly a topic for a different thread.

 

[kmf]

All I've ever harvested is average freezer filler 4x4s or 3x3s and I've hunted a fair amount out there. I always feel like it's your Montana residents deer and I'm on your ground, which I am.

Great deer everyone and I'm enjoying watching it grow.

 

[the nikster]

I have an old buck from the mid eighties that I think dried out to just under 35". I'll try to find a pic, he doesn't exist if I can't find a photo so don't quote me just yet.

 

[the nikster]

Here is a pic of the deer from the eighties. The doorway is 48" and the board the elk antlers are on is 36". The deer has an inside spread of 34 4/8". Chased him for 4 years while he regressed to a 36" wide 5 x 7 with 5" eye guards.

 

[antlerradar]

Is that inside the mainbeams or inside the main points?