Paul in Idaho
Well-known member
I was fortunate to kill a cow elk during my late muzzleloader season. Temperatures ranged from single-digits to below zero, so a warming fire to keep my fingers working seemed like a good idea. Lighting a fire wasn't easy, so I'm posting here to see if any of you have ideas to share.
My fire kit contains dry cotton balls in a sealed pill bottle, a fire steel, "strike anywhere" matches, and neosporin (double duty for first aid). I had tested all these items at home successfully. Unfortunately, it took many tries to get a fire started this time. The cold temperatures are the only thing I can think of as a reason. The cotton balls caught a spark instantly, but never did more than smolder and turn black. There was no flame like there had been during tests.
Since it wasn't an emergency, I experimented with different combinations to see what would work. The cotton didn't even smolder hot enough to ignite a match head it was wrapped around. It wouldn't get hot enough to ignite the petroleum jelly (neosporin) I had wrapped the cotton around either.
Then I switched to matches. So much for "strike anywhere" - it took 10 or more before one finally lit instead of just marking up the surface I tried to strike them on.
A couple days later I was in my base camp and tried again. By then, the temperature had risen to 34, and the cotton ball flamed instantly when the sparks hit it.
When I was a kid, matches could be struck on practically anything - rocks, metal, jeans zippers. Now it seems they just wear off the ignition material and snap and smoke a bit. I thought maybe they got less effective with age, but these were new this year. Back at home, I tried striking them on a disposable fingernail file. Not even that worked.
Even in mild conditions, there's a large number of duds in most boxes. Have any of you had trouble with matches in recent years?
I haven't carried a butane lighter for a while since many designs are hard to operate with gloves or cold fingers. Maybe its time to put one back into the kit.
My fire kit contains dry cotton balls in a sealed pill bottle, a fire steel, "strike anywhere" matches, and neosporin (double duty for first aid). I had tested all these items at home successfully. Unfortunately, it took many tries to get a fire started this time. The cold temperatures are the only thing I can think of as a reason. The cotton balls caught a spark instantly, but never did more than smolder and turn black. There was no flame like there had been during tests.
Since it wasn't an emergency, I experimented with different combinations to see what would work. The cotton didn't even smolder hot enough to ignite a match head it was wrapped around. It wouldn't get hot enough to ignite the petroleum jelly (neosporin) I had wrapped the cotton around either.
Then I switched to matches. So much for "strike anywhere" - it took 10 or more before one finally lit instead of just marking up the surface I tried to strike them on.
A couple days later I was in my base camp and tried again. By then, the temperature had risen to 34, and the cotton ball flamed instantly when the sparks hit it.
When I was a kid, matches could be struck on practically anything - rocks, metal, jeans zippers. Now it seems they just wear off the ignition material and snap and smoke a bit. I thought maybe they got less effective with age, but these were new this year. Back at home, I tried striking them on a disposable fingernail file. Not even that worked.
Even in mild conditions, there's a large number of duds in most boxes. Have any of you had trouble with matches in recent years?
I haven't carried a butane lighter for a while since many designs are hard to operate with gloves or cold fingers. Maybe its time to put one back into the kit.