Advertisement

Anti-Trapping Letter

BigHornRam

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 15, 2004
Messages
14,152
Location
"Land of Giant Rams"
Hey Buzz,

Are you ready to defend your right to trap? As of late, it has been under attack in your home town. A couple weeks ago, a dog that was running loose and was caught in a trap and shoot by the trapper. This has touched off a barage of anti-trapping articles and letters to the editor in the Missoulian. Yesterday had a bleeding heart article about a wolf that was trapped just outside Denali Park in Alaska. Here's a good letter in todays paper.

Trapping only causes suffering
Trapping is antiquated and barbaric, and its demise is surely approaching. Will it expire quietly along with the next few generations of anachronistic "mountain men," or die thrashing and bleeding in the leghold of public outrage?

As trappers rush to castigate dog owners, they conveniently ignore the fact that one of their own put two bullets into the head of a beloved canine companion snared unintentionally in the Bitterroot. So much for the "ethics" of trapping. This incident is a public relations nightmare for trapping associations; no wonder it remains unaddressed while red herrings (dog attacks on humans, dogs as nonnative species) foul the air. You can't defend the indefensible.

Although trapping associations try mightily to wash their garbage with euphemisms, ("humane methods," "furbearer management," "proper predator control"), it's still garbage and belies the fact that trapped animals suffer and suffer horribly. But how do you put a positive spin on an activity driven by greed, ignorance, and a terrifying absence of compassionate humanity? Whether one "harvests" a "fur" for cash or "eliminates predators" out of irrational hatred, wild animals suffer greatly before dying hideous deaths at the hands of people who embody the worst of our species.

If indeed, what goes around comes around, a special circle in hell certainly awaits those humans who visit such intentional pain and cruelty on fellow animals. As for the vast majority of Americans who respond to polls saying they oppose trapping and animal suffering, our continued silence puts us in league with the trappers. We express outrage when the victim is a domestic dog; why are we silent when the intended targets are equally intelligent and feeling wild dogs - foxes and coyotes - which experience the same pain and anguish?

If you call yourself an "animal lover," speak for them.

Kathleen Stachowski, Lolo
 
BHR- Why don't you post the original article. It states the DA will not press charges and the trapper was within his rights to do exactly what he did. The news at 10 stated there was a state wide leash law as well as a follow up interview with a local trapper. I think both sides have been provided quite a bit of air time on this subject and both the Missoulian and the tv news have been quite objective.
 
Matt,

If I posted a bunch articles that agreed with my point of view (which is always the right point of view by the way) then S I would be boring. Kind of like listening to NPR. Don't you prefere it for S I to be a "freak show of political pornography"? What do you think of Kathleens' letter? Pretty good huh. Do you think see donates to all those Missoula based kook obstructionist groups that you and Buzz like to defend and support?
 
BHR- I doubt she donates to any group (other than maybe the Humane Society). I doubt even that.
 
hmm all i can say is it like murdering human when u kill dog becouse as for cops he can be as good as human thenagain like leavin out others well all i know is u suppose kill yotes not dog inless it was dangering u or ur livestock i can see maybe im wrong i dont wanna start arguement why i dont post to most these lol i love animals alot but if they can be dabger i agree they tol be killed leaglly i mean if i am gonna hunt soemthin dang right im eating it a dog u dont eat maybe in africa even humans eaten not bein predijuice but they do even other overseas but here i hunt what i eat only what types said her ei like deer elk and buffaloo good chit :cool:
 
Quiet...
Dogs are not human and really don't react as dogs should when treated as such. There is a new show out called the "Dog Whisperer", it is actually fascinating to watch and see some of these dogs that people have all messed up by treating them as they would a child. He is on the "National Geographic" channel for those of you that get that one.
To the other topic at hand, there are very explicit leash laws for dogs. They need to be leashed when not at home; no matter what ones feelings are on this topic that is the law, and a very good law.
Dogs left to roam have a tendency to chase down and kill any thing they can.
I like the fact that Paul posted this article in the manor he did.
It may have been out of context with what every one else has weighed in on the subject, but as he found it, there probably were no disclaimers or other descriptions of the issue.
So in that context, it is absolutely appropriate to not be displayed with any other dialog except that which we add.
 
I've seen that same issue around here. It's hard for people to take that they were wrong for letting their dog run loose, rather then the trapper being wrong.
 
MTNTOUGH - Use promo code RANDY for 30 days free

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
113,619
Messages
2,026,869
Members
36,245
Latest member
scottbenson
Back
Top