It all comes down to your own style and taste preference. Plus just how much you have to spend, of course. Myself, my style would be the Cartwright in Bourbon Calf. I prefer brown colors over black, but have that in reserve in the closet for funerals and such, like our daughter's wedding. In fact, there are 3 pairs in reserve besides my newer Noconas. Goat, python, lizard, elephant, I've gone through a lot! Buy what looks good to you, that you think will get some more use than just one time.